Skip to content

Of Taste,
Restraint & the
Discipline of Selection.

An Editor’s Note  ·  In Place of a Manifesto

Taste is not a possession one is born to. It is cultivated — quietly, over years — through attention paid to the objects, rooms, garments, and sentences that have already proven they deserve it.

This is a wiki of what endures: a slow index of principles drawn from those who wrote with seriousness on dress, on interiors, on beauty, on music, on the philosophical life. Restraint, here, is not deprivation. It is the form selection takes when one has stopped chasing the new.

The Editors  ·  Spring, MMXXVI
Plate · IThe FrontispieceSilver Gelatin  ·  Untoned
A figure in a white dress, a room, early light
PLATE · IFrontispiece: a single black-and-white photograph — a figure, a window, a room at first light.
After a print in the manner of Penn or Avedon, 1957.“The eye that has learned to wait will refuse, eventually, almost everything.”Reproduced at one-half the original plate.

An Index of the Cultivated Life

Domain I — Dress

After Geneviève Antoine Dariaux — A Guide to Elegance, 1964. Sixty-two entries, A to Z.

A wardrobe is not assembled; it is composed — slowly, by subtraction, around a handful of garments that have already proven themselves equal to the body and the years.

Elegance is a question of personality, more than one of clothing.

Enter the Wardrobe
Two women in an atelier, Victorian dress, 1898
IA coat. A collar. The line of a shoulder.
Pl. IIA grey wool coat, photographed in winter light.1962

Domain II — Interiors

After Edith Wharton & Ogden Codman — The Decoration of Houses, 1897.

A room is governed first by its proportion and only after by its furnishings. To decorate before one has settled the architecture is to dress a sentence before one has written it.

Proportion is the good breeding of architecture.

Enter the Rooms
IIA doorway, a moulding, a length of curtain.
Pl. IIIA panelled drawing-room, morning.c. 1910

Domain III — Music

After Roger Scruton — The Aesthetics of Music, 1997. And after Schubert, Fauré, Pärt.

A piece of music is not a sequence of sounds but a sequence of intentions. To listen is to follow another mind in the act of choosing the next note — and approving its choice.

Music is the art that most rewards the disciplined ear.

Enter the Listening Room
Portrait of a pianist, Seattle, circa 1916
IIIA piano, half-lit. A score on a stand.
Pl. IVAn upright in an empty hall, evening.1958

Domain IV — Beauty

After Roger Scruton — Beauty: A Very Short Introduction, 2009.

Beauty is not decoration. It is a form of judgement — a quiet act of recognition in which a particular thing is permitted to stand for the order it belongs to.

Beauty is not a luxury, but a necessity in which we measure our humanity.

Enter the Argument
A crowd on a ship's deck, divided by a gangway, 1907
IVA vase. A shadow. The pause around an object.
Pl. VA still life, after Morandi.undated

Domain V — Philosophy

After Marcus Aurelius, Montaigne, Pascal, Simone Weil, Scruton. A small shelf, often re-read.

A life is given its form by what it consents to refuse. The philosophical disciplines — attention, patience, the refusal of cleverness — are continuous with the disciplines of dress and of the well-set room.

The eye does not see itself except by reflection. So with the life one is living.

Enter the Common-Place Book
A woman in robes, reading
VA book on a table. A hand. A margin.
Pl. VIAn open volume, annotated.c. 1965

A Few Principles, Held in Common.

These are not rules. They are the propositions one returns to when the eye begins to drift — the editorial conscience of the wiki, restated for each new entry.

i.

Taste is cultivated, not given. It is the residue of years of refusal.

ii.

Restraint is not deprivation. It is the form attention takes once it has matured.

iii.

Selection is the discipline shared by the wardrobe, the room, the ear, and the page.

iv.

What endures is rarely loud. What is loud is rarely re-read.

v.

Proportion precedes ornament. The ornament is the reward for getting the proportion right.

vi.

One does not collect. One keeps company with a small number of things.

Taste is not forced.
It is instilled — by the company
one keeps with what endures.

The Reading List

The books the wiki reads from — on dress, on rooms, on beauty, on music, and on how to live. The list will grow.

Enter the Reading List